Ranking Glastonbury Headliners From Worst to Best

Between 2007 and 2023, I went to the Glastonbury Festival 10 times.

They were truly some of the best days I’ve ever known, and there was a time when I knew that I’d be going to this festival for the rest of my life.

But now it’s more expensive than ever, and it’s getting harder and harder to get tickets. I’m finding less to love on the lineups each year. The site’s getting too big, and large parts of it feel grimly nihilistic, or even outright hostile. I used to think the festival represented humanity at its best. But now I don’t know if I’d even feel welcome there anymore.

Will I ever go again? Who knows. But in any case, I’m immensely grateful for the multitude of life affirming experiences I had there over the course of 16 years. As I attended repeatedly in my formative years, it’s fair to say that the festival’s played a part in making me whatever I am today.

Today I’m ranking every Glastonbury headliner I ever saw in order, from least appealing to most overwhelming. We’re sticking to the Pyramid Stage because, when a Pyramid headliner delivers the goods, it really does feel spiritual. Also, if I delved into the numerous other acts I’ve seen headlining other stages at the festival, we’d be here all day.

Note: When I’ve seen a band play this slot more than once, I shall combine both performances into a single entry. Otherwise we’re just splitting hairs, aren’t we?

Right. Here we go.

Continue reading

Tell The Rabble To Be Quiet

Riot Fest – a punk shindig so alluring that even boring Pink Floyd fans like me yearn to go!

There’s a reason why every festival lineup looks essentially the same these days.

It’s because most festivals are booked by the same handful of promoters.

In America, Live Nation and AEG seem to run the show. The latter controls Coachella, which is presumably why the organisers now obsess over social media metrics when compiling their lineups. Why make memories when you can make money?

Once such titanic promoters get involved, your beloved festival will quickly start to look and feel different. At first, the bland lineups will simply leave you feeling alienated and dispirited. But eventually it will feel like they’re sending a clear message: That you are not invited, and that you are certainly not welcome. Dare to attend and you will feel like an interloping pervert among the influencers, an unsightly human stain lurking in the background of their perfect selfies.

But some festivals manage to retain their independence. And when they retain their independence, they retain their dignity and identity. They still feel like something or somewhere, rather than just another fatberg glistening in a turgid river of grey sludge.

Yes, I am getting old.

Chicago’s Riot Fest is such an independent festival. Every year my brother and I send pictures of the lineup to each other, usually accompanied with such words as “Jesus Christ” or “for God’s sake”. It always looks good, you see. They always manage to put something special together.

For God’s sake.

Continue reading

The Desert Needs a Beer

What’s my age again?

There’s a game some people like to play whenever Coachella unveils the lineup of that year’s festival. You can work out your “musical age” by subtracting from 80 the number of names you recognise on the poster.

Based on the 2025 poster, my musical age is 46. But if I were to calculate it based on the number of acts I’d be interested in watching… hmm!

See for yourself:

The higher your “musical age”, the more you might relate to what follows.

Continue reading

You’re Testing My Mettle, Man

The Monsters of Rock lay down their arms as a rabid dog approached the battlefield looking for a pat on the head. The Download Festival was born.

Why “Download”? Because at the time, people thought that downloading was killing music. So to label a music festival against such a force of evil was a daring move, presumably. Because that’s what metal’s all about: SHOCK. But it raises the question: If the Download Festival were started in 2023 rather than 2003, would they have called it the Streaming Festival?

I’ve only been once, and even then I only went for one day. It was 2019, and the opportunity to see Tool and Smashing Pumpkins on the same day was too good to miss. It was a beautiful day. Everyone was friendly, and everyone was there for the music. I saw more devil horns than smartphones held aloft, and the bars had the Iron Maiden Trooper ale on tap.

Also, Download has a mascot: The Download Dog. He started life looking like an unfortunate victim of experiments in canine ESP. Over the years, he’s also appeared as a sort of FrankenDog, as a snarling pink puppy, and as a skeleton. When he makes public appearances, though, he’s a giant red naked bodybuilder with studded bracelets who, despite his leer and his bulging muscles, looks to be quite cuddly.

All festivals should have a mascot. The Glastonbury Wizard. The Reading Bookworm. The Latitude Accountant. In fact, every business and brand in the land should have a mascot. They help, in a way.

So I’m down with The Download Festival. And that’s why I decided to listen to every band and artist that ever played Download Festival. What else am I going to do with my Spotify subscription?

Continue reading

Reading Before The Fall

What Happened to The Reading and Leeds Festivals?

Every year, as the August Bank Holiday weekend approaches, the Shiiine On Festival shares an old Reading & Leeds lineup to their Instagram.

Something like this:

You can imagine the comments. Some just offer a single word. “Classic,” or similar. Some share fond memories. This is often something along the lines of, “I can’t remember much but I’m told I had a good time”. They were drunk, you see.

But others say something along the lines of “what happened?”

And you get similar comments whenever Reading and Leeds post lineup updates to their own social media profiles. “What happened?”

What happened, indeed?

Continue reading

Neck Deep at ATP

All Tomorrow’s Parties (ATP) was a series of festivals held between 1999 and 2016.

These festivals were remarkable for a number of reasons. First, their lineups were almost entirely hand-picked by a guest curator, who was usually a musician. Second, many of the festivals took place in the most refined environments possible – Butlin’s holiday camps! Yes, this means that for one glorious evening it was possible to see Patti Smith play on a stage usually used for knobbly knees contests.

Continue reading